DRAFT AGENDA

Attendees & Representation

Type @ and your name to indicate your attendance

LF Staff: na

Community: Toshiyasu Wakayama  Ben Hepworth Jose Luis Urien Nick VrionisEric MurrayÁkos Hunyadi  Herbert Damker Thorsten Lohmar Emil Cheung Gervais-Martial Ngueko Joachim Dahlgren Masaharu Hattori Rafal Artych Ramesh Shanmugasundaram Randy Levensalor Surajj Jaggernath 

Agenda

• Antitrust Policy
• Review of previous meeting minutes
• Overall Topics...
• Regular Topics
  • Open Pull Requests
  • New Issues
  • Issues relevant for v0.11.0
• Any Other Topics

...

• Previous meeting minutes: 2024-06-28 Quality on Demand - Meeting Minutes
  • ...no comments

Overall topics

• Commonalities and ICM release candidates available
  • https://github.com/camaraproject/Commonalities/tree/r0.4.0-rc.1
  • https://github.com/camaraproject/IdentityAndConsentManagement/tree/v0.2.0-rc.1
• All Sub Projects are asked to prepare for the meta-release, including creating API release trackers for their APIs under their wiki pages, preparing their release-candidate API version and their API readiness checklist items.
• Target: First release-candidates of API Sub Projects to be provided by 07-21

Open Pull Requests (open for review)

• PR #295 Add required security scheme and scopes by Eric Murray
  • Final review ...
  PR #306 Add #306 Add HTTP-status-codes for better Error Handling
  • Discussion about which After discussion reduced to add HTTP-status-codes should be included within the OAS in the issue #305 Add more HTTP Status Codes for improved Error Handling
    • ...
  • New issues #315 and #316 (see below) might be related and can be covered by this PR?
    • ...
  • code 429
  • Supersedes also the (draft) PR #297 Add error 429 QUOTA_EXCEEDED?
  • Jose Luis Urien will do a cross-check of the PR, also with other APIs like DeviceLocation
  • Target to get it close within next week

• PR #318 Add query to qos-profiles to query profiles available on a given device
  • Addresses #166
  • Open question: one endpoint for all cases?
    • no objections to go with one POST endpoint
    • Randy Levensalor will update the PR

• PR #299 New API QOD Provision
  • Name of API changed to qod-provisioning
  • Request to all to review the latest version within the Pull Request. Please add your comments (or approval) until end of next weeks

• PR #320 New API Readiness Checklists for quality-on-demand and qos-profiles
  • Created and prefilled to check the current status
  • Need to be updated as part of each release PR
  endpoint to be discussed (see comments from Randy Levensalor within the PR). Eric: "provision" is mobile terminology, would be good to avoid.
  • Jorge Garcia Hospital will ask Jose Luis Urien to address the comments.
  To be able to include it within the release candidate we need to conclude the discussions about the PR until the next meeting (starting the final review).

Closed issues

• #309 Purpose of messages array in SessionInfo schema is undocumented
  • Done Closed with PR #312
• #244 Align securitySchemes and security of QOD API spec with IdentityAndConsentManagement
  
  • addressed by PR #295Closed with the merge of PR #295 Add required security scheme and scopes

New Issues

• #313 Align with Commonality decision about optional device object and respective documentation
  • To be done together with #315 and #316
  • Herbert Damker volunteered to do the PR after #306 is merged

• #314 Adding notificationUrl as an optional property in CloudEvents
  • Discussion open, DT will check the proposed alternative from Eric

• #315 Return 422 instead of 501 if the service is not implemented for specified device
  • #316

  Issues relevant for v0.11.0

  • #292 Scope of QualityOnDemand for Fall24 CAMARA release
    
    • Review scope and decide about necessary changes
  • • Together with #313
  • #316 Align error responses for Device Object with v0.4.0 of Design Guidelines
    • Together with #313
  • #317 Application IPs are not shared by OTT for QOD API
    • Backlog item if an enhancement at all
    • Discussion to be continued in the issue
  • #321 Remove unresolved reference within quality-on-demand documentation
    • Herbert Damker to create PR, minor change
  • #322 Remove cucumber code from the repository - decision request
    • no objection to delete the code => PR to be created

  Issues relevant for v0.11.0 (if not yet covered by PRs)

  ...

  • #101 List endpoint for active sessions of authenticated user
    • Jose Luis Urien proposed a list endpoint for provisions within PR #299 and recommends to take this as template
    • PR needs to created soon to get it into the release.
    • Randy: name of the endpoint to be considered, see comment in PR #299
    #166 Extend QoS Profile queries to list profiles based on specific users or devices
    • Use same pattern as above in qos-profiles and change the getSessions from GET to POST with device optional in the body
    • Jose Luis Urien to create the PR.
    • no update (will be done in consistency with #101 by Randy)
    Randy Levensalor will create PR to add the endpoint (adding device object optional)
  • #245 Update and enhance test definition file for QOD API
    • Add issue to decide if we keep "cucumber" directory or update it (Herbert Damker )
    • Request to all participants to consider to contribute current .feature files
  • #257 Error behaviour when session cannot be created due to "time cap" limitation
    • PR #297 replaced by PR #306? (check with Jose Luis Urien )
  • • Regarding cucumber code, see #322
    • Jose Luis Urien will check if internal test definitions can be adapted
    • Most probably we won't have a sufficient test .feature file at M3
    • Target to have it in advance of M4.
    #268 Provision mode for QoD
    See PR 299
  • #286 Review Attribute Descriptions with References to External Specifc
    • No update

  Further Issues

  • • For quality-on-demand there is only one reference (to be deleted), see #321
    • Proposal to move the issue to backlog - agreed

  Review scope and time plan for Release Candidate

  • #292 Scope of QualityOnDemand for Fall24 CAMARA release
    
    • Review scope in light of short-term deadline
  • PR #320 New API Readiness Checklists for quality-on-demand and qos-profiles
    
    • Current open "to be dones":
      • API Definition (open Issues/PRs)
      • DesignguidelinesfromCommonalitiesapplied (open Issues/PRs)
      • BasicAPItestcases & documentation (see #245!)
      • Changelog update (will be done in release PR)
    • User stories and Enhanced API test cases are not mandatory for  0.x API versions
  • Target to have the release candidate PR ready within the next QoD call on July 26th.
  • We will go for the Meta-Release with an "Initial" API Version, which means to keep v0.11.0
    • Why we don't go for "Stable":
      • Lack of prerequisites (test cases, certification of previous version)
      • Too many changes between v0.10.0 and v0.11.0, we should have one cycle where we don't introduce breaking changes
    #302 Providing developers with alternate to QoS profile
    • new enhancement proposal by Mahesh Chapalamadugu 
    • discussion to be continued within the issue
    • Proposal to put into backlog for next release, as the discussion can't be concluded for the current release => put into the issue.

  Any other topics

  • Next QoD meeting will be on July 26th, at 14:00 CEST / 12:00 UTC
  • We don't plan to skip meeting meetings until the release (at least for now).

  ...