2024-04-19 Quality on Demand - Meeting Minutes

Attendees & Representation

Type @ and your name to indicate your attendance

LF Staff: na

Community: Herbert Damker Maximilian Laue Thorsten Lohmar Surajj Jaggernath Eric Murray  Joachim Dahlgren Patrice Conil Rafal Artych Jose Luis Urien Ramesh Shanmugasundaram Randy Levensalor Dominik Fisher,  G Vidal, Masaharu Hattori, Jorge Garcia Hospital Bhabani, Emil Cheung

Agenda

• Antitrust Policy
• Review of previous meeting minutes
  • Agreed
• Overall Topics
• Regular Topics
  • Open Pull Requests
  • New Issues
  • Issues relevant for v0.11.0
  • Scope definition
• Any Other Topics

Minutes

Overall topics

• Patch release v0.10.1 published last week
• Meta-release Fall-24 - timeplan
  • Test meta-release page layout
  • Expected Deliverables from QoD
    • M1 - 30/04
      • (Scope of Commonalities & ICM defined)
      • Initiation of release cycle for API Sub Projects - definition of target version
    • M2 - 15/06
      • (Release candidate of Commonalities + ICM)
    • M3 - 15/06
      • First release candidate of QoD, starting of test implementations
        • Won't fit if there are last minutes changes from Commonalities + ICM
      • Instead an v0.11.0-alpha.1 release as milestone target?
    • M4 - 31/08
      • Last (stable) release candidate of target release from QoD
      • Release Criteria fulfilled (incl validation of the release candidate by two independent implementation of the API)
    • M5 - 15/09
      • public release done

Open Pull Requests

• PR #273 feat: add the statusInfo as parameter to the SessionInfo
  • Ready for merge, Randy Levensalor will approve & merge (done)
• PR #283 Add X-Correlator and other fixes
  • Ready for review (=> AI)
  • Jose Luis Urien is working on his CCLA
• PR #228 and #217 still in draft mode.

New Issues

• #282 Move example outside of allOf in schemas.Duration
  • Will be fixed with PR #283
• #281 startedAt y expiredAt do not follow date-time format
  • Decision: Should be changed in scope of v0.11.0, label added
• #280 Clarification of session creation and startedAt
  • Need to be addressed
  • Potential further issues to be derived from discussion within issue (relation of Session Resource Object vs Network Session)
  • Create a summary issue for "duration" issues (#265, #249, ...)

Existing Issues

• #276 Question on the anyOf in DeviceIpv4Addr
  • According to the discussion within the issue: won't fix (keep it open for another week)
• #268 Provision mode for QoD
  • Proposal approved within API Backlog (see 
  • PR to add it into the scope within README Jorge Garcia Hospital 
  • Do we need a User Story for that? Yes. Jorge Garcia Hospital 
  • If new API, it can be added within the repository as long as we always release it together. New versioning guidelines under discussion in ReleaseManagement allow APIs with different versions in one repository.
• #266 Duration in QoS Session and QoS Profile
• #249 Duration in QosProfile and SessionInfo
  • We need a new issue to discuss the use cases and the expected behavior consistently and together with the extend duration endpoint behavior
  • See action item below - the consolidated issue should also include #280 Clarification of session creation and startedAt
• #265 Proposal to split QoS Sessions and QoS Profiles into two separate API definitions
  • Jose will go forward (after merge of #273) and provide the PR, we will discuss final names based on the PR.

• #257 Error behaviour when session cannot be created due to "time cap" limitation
  • Will be addressed after the split
• #245 Update and enhance test definition file for QOD API
  • Waiting for close of issue within Commonalities (to be able to align contribution with them)
  • Sunny test cases have to added before first release candidate of v0.11.0

Any other topics

• Main actions for next two weeks (copied into the action items):
  • Scope v0.11.0 will be defined on the current labels on the issue => create a scope issue Herbert Damker 
  • Create a summary issue for "duration" issues (#265, #249, ...) Jose Luis Urien Maximilian Laue
  • Split PR Jose Luis Urien 
• Alignment and collaboration with https://github.com/camaraproject/NetworkSliceBooking/tree/main
  • Herbert Damker Thorsten Lohmar Rafal Artych will discuss offline
  • (Update: push of "QoS Profiles towards Network Slice Booking as soon we have the split PR)
• Next QoD will be on May 3rd, at 14:00 CEST / 12:00 UTC

Action items

• Create a summary issue for "duration" issues (#265, #249, ...) Jose Luis Urien Maximilian Laue 03 May 2024 
• Create a summary of the scope definition of v0.11.0 within an issue Herbert Damker 30 Apr 2024 
• Final review and merge of PR #283 (Codeowner & Jose Luis Urien ) 30 Apr 2024 
• Create the "split" PR #265 Jose Luis Urien 26 Apr 2024 (request review comments before the next call)